TREE OF LIFE SHOOTER VERDICT--GUILTY!

 


The perpetrator of the deadliest anti-semitic shooting episode in American history was convicted Friday of all of the 63 criminal counts against him.  In that crime, he murdered 11 worshippers and wounded seven others.  During the trial, Robert Bowers admitted he was responsible for the massacre.

The evidence being 100% against the accused, the defense team offered no defense witnesses after the prosecution rested.  The defense will focus on defending against the death penalty.  Sentencing will occur at a later date.

Traditionally, the defense of a particularly heinous crime involves focusing on the theme that anyone who would do such a thing must be insane, and look for treatment and a life sentence.  The State will brush that defense aside and tell the court not to confuse "pure evil" with "insanity."

Aside from applauding the verdict in this case, my interest is in the government's bringing a "hate crime" charge against the defendant.   They can do it.  The charge is justified.  

But what is the point???  Seriously, no one is going to confuse what this monster did with doing his deeds out of love.  The whole idea of adding "hate crime" to a mass murder is, I think, a waste of ink.  

I have never been a fan of "hate crimes."  A crime is a crime.  The defendant either did it or he did not.  And if he had an evil motive, that comes out in sentencing as a reason for harsher punishment.  Having a category of crimes called "hate crimes" adds nothing to our legal system.

Can we all agree Robert Bowers committed a series of horrible crimes on October 27, 2018?  Can we all agree he deserves the harshest punishment American justice can dish out?  

And can we all agree it is meaningless to add, as an aside: "Oh, and by the way, did you know that his shooting every Jew in sight in a synagogue was motivated by hate?"

And may the victims of these horrible crimes rest in the peace of Almighty God.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

7 Things Lawyers Can't Tell Jurors

OBAMA APPOINTEE DENIES GIULIANI ABILITY TO DEFEND HIMSELF, RESULTS IN $148 MILLION JUDGMENT

Man Framed by Prosecutor Released After 29 Years in Prison Seeking Lawsuit